Criminal Record Checks: Uncovering the Truth To Gain Security

criminal record checks for hiring

Criminal record checks are often used when screening candidates for employment. The purpose is to know if they have previous convictions that could impact their job performance. 

Let’s face it, hiring someone new is a bit like inviting them into your company family. You want to trust them, rely on them, and maybe even share a few office birthday cake mishaps down the line. But before you’re handing out matching company mugs, it’s wise to do your due diligence. That’s where criminal record checks come in – a safety net to catch any potential red flags that might otherwise go unnoticed.

So, we’re here to clear the air and answer the burning questions you might have:

The Big Question: Are Criminal Record Checks Mandatory?

Nope, not always. It depends on the role, the industry, and even your company’s own policies. For certain positions, like working with children or handling sensitive financial data, a clean record might be a non-negotiable. But for other roles, it might not be a requirement. The key takeaway? Check with your legal team to understand the legalities specific to your situation.

Myth Busters: Debunking Common Misconceptions

Alright, let’s tackle some head-scratchers. Here are a few common myths surrounding criminal record checks:

  • Myth #1: A Criminal Record is an Automatic Disqualification: False! A criminal record doesn’t automatically disqualify someone. The key is understanding the nature of the offense, how long ago it occurred, and whether it’s relevant to the job requirements. For example, a speeding ticket from college probably wouldn’t be a deal-breaker for a marketing position.
  • Myth #2: It’s an Invasion of Privacy: Not quite. Candidates are typically informed about criminal record checks upfront, and they usually have to provide written consent before the process begins. It’s all about transparency and ensuring everyone’s on the same page.
  • Myth #3: It’s a Slow and Grueling Process: Technology has streamlined things a lot! Depending on the type of check and the legalities in your area, results can be obtained relatively quickly.

Finding the Balance: Safety and Fairness

Criminal record checks are a balancing act. You want to ensure a safe and secure work environment for your team, but you also want to avoid unfairly discriminating against qualified candidates. Here’s how to strike that balance:

  • Focus on Relevance: Don’t conduct a blanket check for every position. Tailor the type of check to the specific role and its requirements.
  • Be Upfront and Transparent: Inform candidates about your criminal record check policy during the application process. This allows them to make informed decisions and avoid any surprises down the line.
  • Consider Rehabilitation: Life throws curveballs, and people make mistakes. If a candidate has a past offense but has demonstrably moved forward and learned from it, consider taking that into account.

The Human Touch: Beyond the Checkbox

Criminal record checks are a valuable tool, but they shouldn’t be the sole factor in your decision-making. Here’s why a healthy dose of human interaction is crucial:

  • The Story Behind the Record: Sometimes, a criminal record doesn’t tell the whole story. During interviews, use the information as a springboard for a conversation. Give candidates the opportunity to explain the context of the situation and demonstrate their growth since then.
  • Skills and Experience Matter: A criminal record doesn’t define someone’s capabilities. Focus on a candidate’s skills, experience, and cultural fit within your team. Someone with a spotless record might not necessarily be the best fit for the role, and vice versa.
  • Second Chances are Real: We all deserve a chance to learn and grow from our mistakes. If a candidate demonstrates genuine remorse, has a clean record post-offense, and possesses the skills your company needs, consider giving them a fair shot.

2 Types of Criminal Record Checks in the UK

  • Standard Criminal Record Check
  • Enhanced Criminal Record Check

What is Standard Criminal Record Check?

A standard criminal record check, also known as a “standard disclosure,” only shows convictions that are considered “unspent” under the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974.

This means that it shows convictions that have not yet reached the specified time limit for becoming “spent,” or forgiven. A standard disclosure does not show convictions that are considered “spent,” or any cautions, reprimands, or final warnings. This is a more surface-level check that is better suited when only active convictions are of concern and the distant past is not as relevant. 

What is Enhanced Criminal Record Check?

An enhanced criminal record check, which can also be called an “enhanced disclosure,” shows all convictions and cautions, even those that are considered “spent.” This more thorough type of check is usually used for roles that involve working with vulnerable groups, such as children or elderly people.

Criminal record checks may also be required for other types of roles, depending on the nature of the job and the level of trust and responsibility involved. For example, criminal record checks may be required for roles that involve handling sensitive information, such as a role in the government or financial transactions in the banking sector, or for roles that involve working in a position of authority.

How to Conduct Criminal Record Checks?

Criminal record checks are usually conducted by the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS). It is a government agency responsible for checking the records of individuals who work in certain roles.

Employers request a criminal record check by completing a form and providing the necessary documentation and fees. The DBS will then check the candidate’s criminal record and provide the employer with a copy of the report.

Criminal record checks are an important during the process of screening candidates for employment. It guarantees a trustworthy and reliable hire. Moreover, it also help prevent unexpected surprises down the line. Criminal record checks are often used in conjunction with other background checks

However, it’s important for employers to follow all relevant laws and regulations when conducting criminal record checks. And to treat all candidates fairly and equally. It can be easy to overreach when doing this type of check. Also, it could sometimes end up discriminating against prospective candidates given the information not relevant to the job. This type of information is usually specified in some sort of screening policy

criminal record checks

Unlocking the Ideal Employee with Serand

Comprehensive Candidate Profiling

 “Serand doesn’t simply check skills off a list. Our assessments generate in-depth personality profiles, measuring crucial traits like integrity, attention to detail, and adaptability. This provides insights no traditional interview can match.”

Situational Judgement for Real-World Success

“Technical knowledge is only part of the equation. Serand’s job-specific situational judgement questions put candidates into realistic accounting scenarios. Their responses reveal how they think, prioritise, and handle challenges – critical for long-term success.”

Cutting Through Social Desirability Bias

“Serand’s assessments incorporate subtle measures of social desirability, helping pinpoint candidates who are genuinely trustworthy and ethical. This adds a layer of security to your hiring process, vital when handling sensitive financial data.”

Identifying Hidden Potential

Serand’s personality profiling might uncover high-potential candidates whose resumes don’t reflect their full capabilities.

Beyond the Resume

Assessments reveal how candidates think under pressure, their communication style, and their ethical compass. These intangibles are impossible to gauge from a resume alone.

Ready to find employees with not just the right skills, but the right mindset? Discover how Serand’s assessments unlock a deeper understanding of candidates. Ask us a question.